I have been trying to incorporate eyeliner into my almost non existent make up routine. I think it lends a polished look and makes the lashes look 50% better without any mascara application(an upcoming post).
I have tried three brands, Mally waterproof pencils(black, brown, teal), Smashbox cream(black, espresso), & Bonjour waterproof pencils(black, aqua, silver) so far.....The Smashbox is among easiest to apply & correct, the Mally is also easy to apply & stays on, but I think I dislike having to sharpen a eyeliner pencil....I love the colors of the Bonjour for the summer and it stays on, but again I dislike the sharpening aspect...
Did I mention I bought the Bare Escentuals Lid Primer, but hardly ever use it which I'm sure would affect staying power also....I am going to get it together one of these days....